I don’t get the hype: Caraval by Stephanie Garber [REVIEW]

27883214Caraval by Stephanie Garber
First published in January 2017
Tags: Young Adult, Fantasy

Buy: Amazon | Book Depository | B&N 

Source: FairyLoot subscription box 

Rating:  photo two stars_zpsbcb0mxir.png

Whatever you’ve heard about Caraval, it doesn’t compare to the reality. It’s more than just a game or a performance. It’s the closest you’ll ever find to magic in this world . . .

Welcome, welcome to Caraval―Stephanie Garber’s sweeping tale of two sisters who escape their ruthless father when they enter the dangerous intrigue of a legendary game.

Scarlett has never left the tiny island where she and her beloved sister, Tella, live with their powerful, and cruel, father. Now Scarlett’s father has arranged a marriage for her, and Scarlett thinks her dreams of seeing Caraval, the far-away, once-a-year performance where the audience participates in the show, are over.

But this year, Scarlett’s long-dreamt of invitation finally arrives. With the help of a mysterious sailor, Tella whisks Scarlett away to the show. Only, as soon as they arrive, Tella is kidnapped by Caraval’s mastermind organizer, Legend. It turns out that this season’s Caraval revolves around Tella, and whoever finds her first is the winner.

Scarlett has been told that everything that happens during Caraval is only an elaborate performance. But she nevertheless becomes enmeshed in a game of love, heartbreak, and magic with the other players in the game. And whether Caraval is real or not, she must find Tella before the five nights of the game are over, a dangerous domino effect of consequences is set off, and her sister disappears forever.

I don’t know, you guys, I’m the black sheep again.


This one just didn’t live up to the hype. I actually really disliked it for the most part and I’m having trouble understanding the hype at all. 

Sometimes I dislike books but still understand why people love them, like A Darker Shade of Magic. Those books aren’t bad at all, I was just personally bored by them for some reason. With this though… I think it’s a bad book. If you like it that’s great, I wish I did, but just… no. 

To make sure this review won’t be five hundred miles long, I’m just going to do it mostly in list form in the hopes that it will shorten it a little. 

But first, in case you didn’t bother reading the long synopsis, here’s the short version. Scarlett and Tella live with their controlling and abusive father. For years since she was a child, Scarlett’s been sending letters to Legend, the master of the legendary Caraval, a magical performance/game that changes locations every year, asking him to please bring Caraval to their island so she can experience the magic. Then suddenly one year, she receives a personal invitation from Legend himself. But once at Caraval, accompanied by a mysterious and hunky sailor, Tella disappears, and Scarlett realizes the game revolves around getting Tella back alive. 

Alright, so that’s a pretty interesting premise. A magical game that may or may not have life or death consequences. Alright, I’m on board. But it fell so very flat. 

  • The beginning was promising, I was into it then. The letters sent to Legend, and then finally the reply. I’m intrigued! But then… 
  • There’s no worldbuilding. There’s “The Conquered Isles”, but conquered by who? How? When? I don’t remember for sure if these questions were addressed but  I’m pretty sure they weren’t
  • The characters are one dimensional. I barely know who the main character is at all. I developed no emotional connection to them, so when something bad happened to them I was just like… *shrugs*
  • There’s instalove disguised as slow-burn. You guys, just because it takes over half the book for the girl to sort of admit she likes the guy, that doesn’t make it slow-burn. At least not to me. It still takes place in the span of five days, where the first three or so days dislikes/suspects Julian and pushes him away. You want me to believe she’s in love with him at the end of the game? Nah. I’m not convinced. Try again. You know what book(s) does slow-burn really well? The Raven Cycle. Fair enough, it’s a series of four books and thus have more time to develop relationships, but as far as I know Caraval is a duology. There didn’t have to be love after five days, at least when considering how much Julian lied to Scarlett in the span of those five days. Give the girl some time, man. 
  • At one points towards the end, Scarlett tells Tella (her sister) “You can’t be in love with someone you just met.” ?????? Is she not self-aware at all? 
  • Plus, Julian is a creep. He keeps coming onto Scarlett despite her clearly pulling away and saying “dude no, I’m engaged.” Their whole relationship, plus their physical descriptions, made me think of things like:

Bilderesultat for romance novel cover pirate

  • The writing isn’t terrible, but it was very cringey at times. Like  “he tasted like midnight and wind” is too much for me. War flashbacks to Shatter Me. 
  • I like that Scarlett has synesthesia, I do a little cheer the rare times I see it in books. In her case she associates/sees colors connected to her emotions. I have it too (different kinds though) so it’s just a fun thing to see
  • I do like the idea that this is a book about sisters and their strong bond. But is it though or does it just pretend to be?? Sure, the premise of the book is that Scarlett’s sister has been kidnapped at the goal of the game is to find her. But I found the swarmy romance too overbearing, it didn’t have to be there and it took away from the sisterly feel
  • It just wasn’t magical enough. It promised me magic, Scarlett spent years writing to Legend about wanting to see his amazing magical performers, but did I get said magic? Not really. There’s a gown that changes with your mood and some Alice in Wonderland-like surrealism (that I’ve never been into personally) and potions that do various things. If you’re a fan of high fantasy and/or complex magic systems, don’t read this. The magic is never really explained or explored
  • It’s not clever enough. The clues they get in the game are weak and Scarlett just randomly seems to figure out each clue, like “oh, that must be it!” and I’m just like… that’s all? It’s not going to attempt to be more clever than that?
  • I admit I had to laugh when the poem I cringed at in the beginning was at the end referred to as “a poorly written poem”. Well, at least it was intentional?? Or maybe the author just can’t write poetry and had Scarlett describe it as poorly written to cover her ass…
  • I’ll also say that while I found myself skimming a lot between the dialogue because I just couldn’t wait for it to be over, it wasn’t slow, which is something that tends to really bring my enjoyment down. Things happened and kept happening, and I guess I can see how that could make you like this book, but again, I didn’t like the way those things happened. Scarlett figured out the clues way too easily and just kept jumping from one event to another
  • The last fifty pages, however, are pretty great. I was pleasantly surprised because I loved the plot twist. Finally something truly interesting! I was originally going to give it 2.5 stars instead of 2 for that twist, but then I figured… nah, the road to said twist was too lackluster to deserve it
  • Also, does this book really need a map? (answer: no)

In short, Caraval is lackluster and overhyped with cardboard characters and creepy instalove disguised as slow-burn. If you’re a fantasy buff looking for dazzling magic and deadly games, avoid this. 

I wanted more magic, less cheesy romance, more sisterhood, and more immersive writing. 


Excuse me, Scarlett, but you’ve known this guy for five days and you think it’s a hard choice to decide who to bring back to life, him or your sister, who you have struggled to protect all your life and have spent the entire game desperately trying to save??? Fuck that noise. I know she ultimately says it’s an easy choice and of course she picks Tella, but that doubt still rubbed me the wrong way and only served to really drive that instalove home. 

And I’m intrigued to find out who Legend actually is, I don’t mind that we haven’t seen him yet and I like the idea of a villain trying to redeem himself because even he can tell he crossed the line, but he still can’t help himself from messing with people’s heads a little too much. In the right author’s hands I think he could be a superb character.

I’m not sure if I want to read the sequel. Maybe. 

me before you review blog

Have you read Caraval? What did you think? I’d love to hear from you no matter if our opinions are vastly different 😀
Follow me on Twitter | Goodreads | Bloglovin’ | Instagram

24 thoughts on “I don’t get the hype: Caraval by Stephanie Garber [REVIEW]

  1. kirstyandthecatread says:

    I’m avoiding this book like the plague. My experience with books by debut authors where the book has been hyped as much as this one is I’m always disapointed I think they are usually enjoyed by people who review in excessive gifs and fangirl lingo and I sometimes wish I was a little more like that but it’s not for me

    Liked by 1 person

    • Anette Reads says:

      I probably wouldn’t have picked this up if I didn’t get it in a subscription box. Yeah, I’d advice you not to read this one. I suppose it has potential to get better in the next one, but I don’t think I’ll bother.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Eve Messenger says:

    THIS is my favorite kind of review–insightful, straightforward, and smartly referencing other books. So true that Raven Cycle does slow-burn so well. As for Caravel, I don’t get the hype either and I haven’t even read it yet, ha.


    • Anette Reads says:

      Oh, thank you so much! What’s so great about The Raven Cycle is that while we know the characters really care about each other, they’re not just jumping straight into each other’s arms after a week of barely interacting. We have to really and truly wait for it.

      I wouldn’t recommend you read this hahaha. I’m so confused why it has so many five star reviews.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Anette Reads says:

      This far almost all my Goodreads friends who have read it have rated it either a 5 or 4. I wouldn’t have picked it up either if I didn’t get it in the subscription box. At least I don’t feel like I wasted my money because the rest of the box was so great.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Liam @ Hey Ashers! says:

    This review is amazing, Anette. I’d already dropped Caraval from my TBR after seeing several other lackluster reviews, but now I’m doubly convinced that this book should never touch my bookshelf. The creepyish romance and the first spoiler you mentioned at the end of your review especially piss me off. (I’m over here fuming from just reading your mention of them.) Thanks for the warnings!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Anette Reads says:

      Thank you, Liam! I think you definitely made the right choice in taking it off your tbr. That one made me so angry. If only it had been phrased in such a way that showed how wrong it feels to have to choose one life over another, but no, it was just “omg my sister or this random guy I just met idk such a hard choice???” No sir.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Kelly says:

    Sorry to hear that this wasn’t a favorite! I know almost everyone loved this book, and to be honest, I think yours is the first review that has mentioned the fact that the world building was a tad lackluster. I noticed that there wasn’t really any detail over who had conquered the islands, either, and that really bummed me out. I also had a hard time putting together the whole of the world of Caraval, because it could have used a lot more detail. While I really did love the book (it’s the first time I haven’t been the black sheep when it comes to a popular book), I definitely think more detail could have been paid to the writing and descriptions. I’m really hoping that we learn more of a backstory in the sequel.

    Your review was simply amazing, by the way!


  5. Geronimo Reads says:

    Sorry to hear you didn’t like it! It’s totally understandable though. I had my doubts going into at first but the second half of the book just blew my mind. I’m on the opposite end and have a weird thing for Julian haha. But we all can’t agree on liking the same thing! Your review was still very good and informational.


  6. Reg @ She Latitude says:

    I gave this book 3.5 stars but I actually totally agree with most of what you said. The relationship between Scarlett and Tella felt very much ‘tell’ instead of ‘show’ for me and failed, and the romance was… not good. Just not good, haha. I also didn’t like that it was super deus ex machina-ey, especially towards the end. I think I enjoyed the writing better than you did, but for the most part it didn’t live up to the hype either for me. 😛


  7. Sara @ freadomlibrary says:

    I’ve heard some complaints about this book recently, it’s just kind of annoying how they tend to come out after its released and on the best sellers list. Some people are talking about the abuse and how it’s dealt with in kind of a bad way and now I’m just not even interested haha


  8. Zezee says:

    I read the book and I agree with the critiques you mentioned above. I was intrigued at first, but once the Caraval got going, my interest in the book started to falter. Part of my dislike was because it’s often said to be like The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern (which I assumed meant the writing was similar as well), but it wasn’t. I also cringed at the writing. I could see what the author was trying to accomplish, but it didn’t get there so the descriptions turned me. And I also agree there’s not much world building or character development. I didn’t get why it’s so hyped either.
    I think it’s pretending to be about the strong bond between the sisters. The story doesn’t focus on it much and Scarlet spends the majority of her time criticizing her sister. By the end of the book, I thought Tella’s actions were manipulative so I don’t think the relationship between them is the best.


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s